VAR audio released from Liverpool's disallowed goal by Luis Diaz in defeat at Spurs
Luis Diaz's goal for Liverpool at Tottenham was mistakenly disallowed by the officials; VAR failed to overturn an incorrect offside call after believing the on-field decision had been to award the goal; PGMOL admitted VAR officials Darren England and Dan Cook failed to act
Wednesday 4 October 2023 22:12, UK
The VAR audio from Luis Diaz's wrongly disallowed goal for Liverpool at Tottenham has been released by the PGMOL, revealing the replay operator was the only person to immediately spot the mistake and urge the officials to stop the game.
Diaz was flagged offside after scoring but replays showed he was actually onside.
But Darren England, the VAR, mistakenly believed the on-field decision had been to award the goal, leading him to tell Simon Hooper, the referee, that the check was complete.
After England and the assistant VAR Dan Cook were alerted to their mistake by the replay operator when the goal wasn't awarded, they repeatedly said they could not intervene as the game had restarted.
"Can't do anything," said England as the replay operator asked for the game to be stopped.
Trending
- Usyk denies Fury in intense world championship rematch
- Highlights: Usyk overcomes Fury in epic heavyweight rematch
- Big fight reaction: What next for Fury and Usyk after contentious call?
- Fury rages: I was robbed... Usyk got a Christmas gift!
- 'He got a Christmas gift!' | Fury left fuming in post-fight press conference
- Papers: Arsenal, Man City and Bayern in three-way battle for Olmo
- 'Uncle Frank is blind!' | Usyk responds to Fury complaints
- Littler tested on emotional Worlds return: 'Never felt anything like that'
- Fury's FURIOUS backstage reaction after defeat | 'I won by at least three rounds!'
- PL hits & misses: Arsenal are title-race ready, Man City are ordinary
In an increasingly-frantic exchange, the unnamed replay operator says: "Oli's calling in to say delay the game. The decision is onside".
- Listen to VAR audio from disallowed Luis Diaz goal
- Ref Watch: One little question would have prevented terrible mistake
- VARs England and Cook stood down amid VAR controversy
It's understood that the 'Oli' referred to is Oli Kohout, the VAR Hub Operations executive.
Audio from fourth official Michael Oliver is not included in the clip.
As the replay operator continues to try to stop the game, England states "can't do anything" five more times before Cook agrees by adding: "They've restarted".
No further communication with on-field referee Hooper is included. Sky Sports has reported that Hooper was first informed of the error at half-time.
- Jamie Carragher: VAR 'panicked' and 'froze' when disallowing goal
- Stream the Premier League and more with NOW for £21 a month for six months
In a statement to accompany the release of the audio, the PGMOL accepted "standards fell short of expectations" and confirmed a "detailed report, including the key learnings and immediate actions taken, has been submitted to the Premier League, who have shared it with Liverpool FC and subsequently all other Premier League clubs".
According to the PGMOL, those key learnings include:
- Guidance to Video Match Officials has always emphasised the need for efficiency, but never at the expense of accuracy. This principle will be clearly reiterated
- A new VAR Communication Protocol will be developed to enhance the clarity of communication between the referee and the VAR team in relation to on-field decisions
- As an additional step to the process, the VAR will confirm the outcome of the VAR check process with the AVAR before confirming the final decision to the on-field officials
There has been widespread criticism that England and Cook were permitted to officiate in the United Arab Emirates for a match which took place hich took place just 48 hours before the Tottenham vs Liverpool game.
The PGMOL, along with the FA, pledged to review the policy to allow match officials to officiate matches outside of FIFA or UEFA appointments.
What's said in the audio: Read the full transcript here
This is the transcript of what was said between the officials. The on-field referee does not hear all of the audio from the VAR room - only those comments directed to him.
Assistant referee 1: "Waiting. Delaying, delaying."
VAR: "Possible offside, Diaz."
Assistant referee 1: "Coming back for the offside, mate."
VAR: "Just checking the offside, Delay, delay."
VAR: "Give the kick point, let's go. Kick point, please?"
Referee: "Yeah, no worries, mate."
Replay operator: "So here we are."
Referee: "Wait."
Replay operator: "Just get a tight angle."
VAR: "Yeah, give me a 2D line ready after this one for frame two after that."
Replay operator: "So frame two there?"
VAR: "That's fine."
VAR: "Perfect, yeah."
VAR: "2D line on the left boot."
Replay operator: "Let me just switch angles."
VAR: "Romero, I think it is?"
Replay operator: "I think it might be this angle [that is] better? Happy with this angle?"
VAR: "Yep."
Replay operator: "2D line on the boot?"
VAR: "2D line on the left boot."
Replay operator: "Yeah, okay."
Replay operator: "So, 2D line on the boot."
VAR: "And stop."
VAR: "Check complete, check complete. That's fine, perfect."
Assistant referee 1: "Playing."
Referee: "Cheers, mate."
VAR: "Thank you, mate."
Referee: "Well done, boys. Good process."
Replay operator: "Wait, wait, wait, wait. The on-field decision was offside."
Replay operator: "Are you happy with this?"
Assistant VAR: "Yeah."
Replay operator: "Are you happy with this?"
Assistant VAR: "Offside, goal, yeah."
Assistant VAR: "That's wrong that, Daz."
VAR: "What?"
Replay operator: "On-field decision was offside. Are you happy with this image? Yeah, it's onside. The image that we gave them is onside."
Assistant VAR: "The left-back he's played him, he's gone."
VAR: "Oh [expletive]."
Replay operator: "Delay, delay."
Replay operator: "Oli's [PGMOL Hub Ops] saying to delay, Oli's saying to delay."
VAR: "Pardon?"
Replay operator: "Oli's calling in to say delay the game. The decision is onside."
VAR: "Can't do anything."
Replay operator: "Oli's saying to delay, Oli's saying to delay."
VAR: "Oli?"
Fourth official: "Yeah?"
Replay operator: "Delay the game, delay the game. Stop the game."
VAR: "They've restarted the game. Can't do anything, can't do anything."
Assistant VAR: "Yeah, they've restarted. Yeah."
VAR: "Can't do anything."
Assistant VAR: "No."
VAR: "I can't do anything. I can't do anything. *Expletive*."
Ref Watch: One little question would've prevented 'terrible mistake'
Sky Sports' Dermot Gallagher:
"It was a terrible mistake to make. Everyone has acknowledged that.
"It's now about the process and one of the processes is they will have to undertake from now is the VAR will have to ask the referee: 'what is the on-field decision?'
"If that little question had been asked and [Simon Hooper] said "offside" then you've got a starting point. Then you can go forward. Unfortunately, because that question wasn't asked, they were under the impression the goal had been given on the field and that's how everything unfolded."
Analysis: Protocols will change, lessons will be learned
Sky Sports News chief reporter Kaveh Solhekol:
"Listening to the audio, I keep wondering why they were in such a rush to make that decision.
"They are being put under pressure to make these decisions really quickly. When VAR was first introduced, and they were taking a long time to make these decisions, everyone was complaining about the fact it was taking too long.
"People in the stadiums didn't know what was going on either, so I think that's why they've tried to speed up the decision-making process.
"But listening to the audio, it's obvious that if you do anything at that speed, and so many people are watching and depending on your decision-making, mistakes are going to be made."