Skip to content
Analysis

Premier League hits and misses: Illan Meslier conceded 11 goals from 11 shots on target - why does he remain undroppable?

Plus: Liverpool show people just what might have been this season in dominant display with Trent Alexander-Arnold pulling the strings

Masterful Liverpool show what could have been

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

FREE TO WATCH: Highlights of Leeds against Liverpool in the Premier League.

Liverpool's creativity was simply sublime. Unstoppable. They cut through Leeds like a knife through butter. Javi Gracia's side put up little resistance but the attacking output from Liverpool was near-impossible to combat, epitomised by the sensational Trent Alexander-Arnold.

The full-back-cum-midfielder touched the ball 153 times at Elland Road. That's the second-most of any player all season. He dictated and commanded the middle of the park, alongside Fabinho, while sparking wave after wave of attack. His influence was greater than any other, delivering an assist in each half, taking his league tally to 50 overall.

Liverpool's Trent Alexander-Arnold, right, and Liverpool's Mohamed Salah celebrate after Liverpool's Cody Gakpo scored his side's opening goal during the English Premier League soccer match between Leeds United and Liverpool at Elland Road in Leeds, England, Monday, April 17, 2023. (AP Photo/Rui Vieira)
Image: Trent Alexander-Arnold registered two assists against Leeds

"There are very few players in world football - bar Kevin De Bruyne - who can match him in that area," Sky Sports' Jamie Carragher said when analysing the 24-year-old's impressive contribution.

Klopp was equally gushing. "Trent played a really really good game," he told Sky Sports. "The formation suits us much better," the German added. If only the realisation had hit Klopp sooner.

GRAPHIC

This is not the first time Liverpool have been breathtaking this term - they blew away Man United with a seven-goal thrashing not long ago. But this is the first occasion away from Anfield that they have delivered such a ruthless, yet slick display. The kind of performance Premier League onlookers got accustomed to enjoying week-in-week-out a few seasons back. It begs the question - 'what could have been?'

Klopp can afford to be experimental with the remainder of this campaign. There is very little for Liverpool to play for, although a surprise late push for a top four spot isn't beyond the realms. This will serve as a timely reminder - Liverpool still have class. It's inconsistency that remains their biggest foe.
Laura Hunter

Also See:

Is it time to drop Meslier?

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

The Mirror's Chief Football Writer, John Cross questions if Javi Gracia can turn the negativity around at Leeds after two heavy home defeats from Liverpool and Crystal Palace.

"They look like they've got a kid in goal - he's got no presence," said Jamie Carragher when asked why Leeds have so many issues with keeping the ball out of their net.

Leeds goalkeeper Illan Meslier isn't a kid anymore though. He turned 23 last month but is the youngest goalkeeper in Premier League history to rack up 100 appearances. The shirt has been his ever since Marcelo Bielsa put ultimate faith in his ability with a clear liking for his savvy use of the ball. However, is he developing at the rate you'd expect with a goalkeeper playing at this level? That is certainly up for debate when assessing his record in the past two seasons.

Consecutive shots on target conceded since 2006/07 (exc. own goals)

End of run Goalkeeper Consecutive SOT conceded
17/04/2023 Illan Meslier 11
19/12/2020 Vicente Guaita 8
16/12/2009 Chris Kirkland 8
28/12/2021 Angus Gunn 7
28/08/2021 Tim Krul 7
08/04/2017 Claudio Bravo 7
09/11/2014 Hugo Lloris 7
07/12/2013 Petr Cech 7
01/04/2012 Pepe Reina 7
27/11/2010 Paul Robinson 7
19/12/2009 Shay Given 7

Although he wasn't at obvious fault for any of the Liverpool goals, the damming statistic of him conceding 11 shots on target in a row over two consecutive games doesn't look good.

Trying to showcase how important a goalkeeper is to their side is a difficult conundrum but a starting point is to analyse the expected goals data and see whether that goalkeeper is overperforming or underperforming when it comes to quality of chances being fired at his goal. Well, he underperformed by 16.8 goals last season - the worst record of any Premier League goalkeeper. And he's at an underperformance of 7.8 this season - only Gavin Bazunu (9.74) is performing worse in that regard.

Maybe it's time for a change to try and ignite some stability back there for a Leeds team that is out of control defensively.
Lewis Jones

Arsenal's shine is fading

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

FREE TO WATCH: Highlights from the 2-2 draw between West Ham and Arsenal in the Premier League

When Bukayo Saka put his penalty at West Ham wide of goal, it was the sign of how things can move away from the norm in a title race.

Saka is normally so reliable from the spot. His four previous spot kicks - against Manchester City, Liverpool, Manchester United and Chelsea - all went in.

But the temperature is rising in the UK and so is the pressure in the title race. At West Ham, it got to Saka, it got to this young Arsenal team.

The last two Sundays are not how Arsenal have been this season. Mikel Arteta's side have been consistent all term. Free from injuries, fast starts, managing games, good responses to setbacks, fortunate with VAR calls, dramatic finishes.

Fast starts have been there in their recent away games at Liverpool and West Ham. But the rest has not. Now there are back-to-back slip-ups emanating from similar circumstances. Two-nil up. Sloppy error before half time to make it 2-1. Equaliser in the second half. Not enough to grab the game back.

Just like in the first 30 minutes at Liverpool, Arsenal played like champions at West Ham. Their performance was the perfect response to Manchester City's game with Leicester to go 2-0. But the same unfortunate themes came up.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Arsenal manager Mikel Arteta reflects on a disappointing result for his side against West Ham, after surrendering a two-goal lead at the London Stadium

Bukayo Saka's penalty miss two minutes before Jarrod Bowen's equaliser for 2-2 is the flashpoint moment - but Arsenal threw it away when Thomas Partey's lapse in concentration allowed the Hammers to get their penalty for 1-2.

Arsenal's consistency has been something to marvel this season. They have kept the same starting team all season but got us on the edge of our seats week in, week out. They have dazzled us with late winners against Liverpool, Aston Villa, Bournemouth and Manchester United. They have bounced back when everyone expected a crumble.

Perhaps the shine of this young team is fading. They need to bounce back again in time for the Manchester City trip in under two weeks.
Sam Blitz

Fernandes can flap all he wants

Manchester United's Bruno Fernandes during the English Premier League soccer match between Nottingham Forest and Manchester United at City ground in Nottingham, England, Sunday, April 16, 2023. (AP Photo/Rui Vieira)
Image: Manchester United have won 15 and lost none of the 17 matches in which Bruno Fernandes, Casemiro and Christian Eriksen have all started together in all competitions (D2), a win rate of 88 per cent

In an interview with Sky Sports this week, Bruno Fernandes conceded emotions sometimes get the better of him when he pulls on a Manchester United - or any - shirt. It's an underlining principle of his game which delivers both good and bad consequences.

At Anfield in March, when Manchester United were embarrassed like never before at the hands of rivals Liverpool, Fernandes' gesticulation and protests drew widespread condemnation from club legends Gary Neville and Roy Keane.

Fernandes, a player who has perhaps grasped what it means to play for Manchester United more than any other during the post Sir Alex Ferguson era, could not contain his frustration as seven Liverpool goals hit the net, clashing with a linesman and prompting calls for the ugly side of his game to be banished for good.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

FREE TO WATCH: Highlights from Manchester United’s win against Nottingham Forest in the Premier League.

But to take that passion out of Fernandes' game would be to deny the Portuguese of the very instincts which have propelled him to the elite-level in which he resides. His footballing currency is passion and emotion, which when tuned appropriately can deliver peerless results.

Look no further than Manchester United's 2-0 victory at Nottingham Forest on Sunday for a timely reminder of this very point. Fernandes didn't even score yet he left the field the game's standout player after a mesmeric display of attacking creativity and awareness.

After his performance at the City Ground, ask any Manchester United fan if they would change Fernandes' unique outlook on football. It goes without saying what the answer would be. For when he is firing, Fernandes can flap all he wants.
Jack Wilkinson

West Ham aggression will please fans

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Jarrod Bowen dealt Arsenal a hammer blow with his leveller in their crucial Premier League clash

Such was the emphasis on the title race and the drama of Arsenal faltering that West Ham's own need for points took second billing but this was a big point for David Moyes and his team. The aggression showed in turning the match will encourage supporters.

Declan Rice had no right to be pressing Thomas Partey as he did in the build-up to the penalty won by Lucas Paqueta. At a time when Arsenal had looked to be in total control, the West Ham captain took it upon himself to carry the fight back at the leaders.

Where Rice led, the rest followed - on and off the pitch. If this was an audition for the England man to show Arsenal and others just what he brings to the table, then the part is surely his. He was monstrous in the West Ham midfield, covering 11.2km in the match as he and Tomas Soucek ran themselves into the ground.

Suddenly, after the Bukayo Saka miss, the home side were winning the duels and the supporters were up again. The point takes them four points clear of the bottom three. The battling qualities will have them believing they can stay out of trouble. And with a player like Rice in their midfield they should be nowhere near the Championship. Champions League more like.
Lewis Jones

Forest now need to find something special to avoid the drop

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Nottingham Forest head coach Steve Cooper says it was a 'bad error' from the referee for not awarding a penalty to his side in the game against Manchester United.

Nottingham Forest owner Evangelos Marinakis had called for an immediate improvement in results when he backed head coach Steve Cooper last week. Two defeats later, it feels like a sudden transformation for this side is unlikely.

In fact, after a comprehensive defeat to Manchester United, their position could well get worse before it gets better.

Next weekend they go to Anfield. Then it's in-form Brighton at the City Ground before a trip to Brentford - never an easy away day. In that space of time, Everton - level on Forest with points but with a better goal difference - could edge away from the drop zone with games against Crystal Palace and Leicester.

Forest's home game with bottom-club Southampton on Sky Sports on May 8 is now a must-win. There's no two ways about it. There are then games with Chelsea and Arsenal before their season finale at Crystal Palace - another one they have to take three points from.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Roy Keane and Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink analyse the handball penalty shout against Harry Maguire at Nottingham Forest.

But two more wins would only take Forest to 33 points - shy of the 37-point mark which has been the target for relegation-threatened clubs in recent times. Even in this exceptional season, with more teams in danger than usual, it feels like Forest will need to cause an upset somewhere along the way.

To do that, they cannot afford to be as open as they were against Man Utd, allowing the visitors' midfield time and space. They must capitalise on set-piece opportunities, such as the one which saw Felipe head over from two yards out. They must be clinical in front of goal, a ruthlessness Taiwo Awoniyi was missing on Sunday. And they are going to need some fortune, which was absent when Harry Maguire got away with a handball in his own box.

It's not over yet and the difference between third-bottom and safety is just goal difference. But the games are running out, the stakes are going up and a Forest side which hasn't tasted victory in 10 matches need to find something special.
Peter Smith

Win £250,000 with Super 6!
Win £250,000 with Super 6!

Could you win £250,000 for free on Tuesday with Super 6? Entries by 8pm, good luck!

Around Sky