England are considering playing Marcus Smith at full-back with Fin Smith at fly-half in their backline against France in the hope of igniting their Guinness Six Nations campaign on Saturday.
Marcus Smith has been first choice fly-half since the 2023 World Cup but could be moved to full-back for Saturday's Allianz Stadium showdown to accommodate his namesake's promotion to the starting XV.
Fin Smith has made all seven of his previous Test appearances as a replacement, meaning his full debut would come in a game of critical importance with England playing to save their championship after losing 27-22 to Ireland in round one.
- Six Nations: Fixtures and results from 2025 tournament 📋
- Ireland 27-22 England | France 43-0 Wales | Scotland 31-19 Italy
- Not got Sky? Get Sky Sports or stream no contract on NOW 📺
The Northampton rookie would have responsibility for directing the backline with Marcus Smith providing a counter-attacking threat from 15, a position he first filled at the World Cup and has occupied in cameos since.
England head coach Steve Borthwick is also considering handing Saracens' Tom Willis his first Test start in the back row.
'Fin Smith has all the things you associate with top 10s'
Selecting two of English rugby's most creative talents together in Marcus and Fin Smith would offer an extra dimension with the ball in hand, although Freddie Steward's demotion at full-back would also rob the team of their aerial master.
Attack coach Richard Wigglesworth said: "Marcus is obviously another set of eyes that are very opportunistic. Where's the space? Who can I beat?
"But Freddie Steward brings an incredible level of high-ball skill and a kick return that is incredibly decisive on the way back. There are competing demands that you are trading off all the time.
"We are blessed with having three 10s that can all play international rugby to a high level. Fin has had less chance than the rest at the moment, but he is really clear with his game, he is confident without being arrogant and wants to get better.
"He has all the things that you associate with top 10s. He's really clear with what he wants and how to best position the team."
Inside centre Henry Slade will be working in tandem with whoever is chosen at fly-half against France, and the Exeter back insists both have unique skill sets.
"Fin sees space really well. There's always going to be space on the field somewhere, you can't defend everything, and he sees it really well," Slade said.
"Obviously he's a slightly different 10 to Marcus. Marcus has got that X factor in terms of beating a man one-on-one and all that stuff, but Fin is very measured. He speaks very well.
"A big part of a number 10's role is moving the team around to where they need to be on the pitch and he's been really good at that."
England 'gutted' after Murley injury
Cadan Murley has been ruled out against France after suffering a foot injury on his Test debut in Dublin on Saturday, but could return in time for the end of the Six Nations.
"We're gutted for Cadan because what he's done is overcome a huge amount of injuries," Wigglesworth said.
"He gets his opportunity, he scores and assists and then he's not able to be in the mix again the week after.
I'm delighted that he got his chance and really disappointed for him that it's been taken away pretty quickly."
Going with Fin over Marcus in the pick of Smiths would be bold
If Steve Borthwick does indeed decide to pick Fin Smith head of Marcus Smith this weekend against France, it would be a very bold and significant selection decision.
Marcus Smith has been England's first choice fly-half since the 2023 Rugby World Cup. He's started the last eight Tests at 10 for England. However, over those last eight games, England have lacked consistency and have failed to beat a Tier 1 nation.
Fin Smith is just 22-years-old, and he's never started a Test. But there is a feeling among some former players his game is better suited to international rugby than Marcus Smith's. The basis of that argument being: while Marcus Smith can produce moments of brilliance that unlock defences, Fin Smith's game-management is better.
And it is game management where England have really struggled over the last nine months, consistently losing Tests in the final third.
If Marcus moves to full-back and Fin takes the reigns at fly-half, maybe England can utilise the best of both young talents.
Six Nations fixtures: Round Two
Saturday February 8
Italy vs Wales (2.15pm)
England vs France (4.45pm)
Sunday February 9
Scotland vs Ireland (3pm)