Skip to content

Linares vs Crolla II: The Panel give verdict on battle of Manchester bands ahead of Saturday's rematch

Ricky Hatton with Liam and Noel Gallagher
Image: Ricky Hatton's legion of fans included the Oasis duo of Liam and Noel Gallagher

Ahead of Anthony Crolla's rematch with Jorge Linares, we asked The Panel to give their verdict on another Manchester battle between Oasis and The Stone Roses.

Hometown hero Crolla will attempt to regain the WBA lightweight title when he faces Linares for a second time this Saturday night at the Manchester Arena.

A number of Britain's best loved bands have also thrived in the city, alongside its successful sportsman, and we have asked our experts to adjudicate a straight fight between two of the biggest - Oasis and The Stone Roses.

LINARES-CROLLA 2
Image: Manchester's Anthony Crolla will face Jorge Linares in Saturday's rematch

Ricky Hatton

Oasis. Imagine what it was like when Liam and Noel carried my belts into the ring when I fought Paulie Malignaggi in Las Vegas.
Ricky Hatton, Noel and Liam Gallagher
Image: Hatton was joined in the ring by Noel and Liam after his win over Paulie Malignaggi

There have been so, so many songs. I used to love 'Stay Young' and still do, because we'd all want to, and that was one of the early ones.

'Champagne Supernova', 'She's Electric' were always on in the gym and the dressing room before a fight.

Live Fight Night

Carl Froch

Rob McCracken was more of a Stone Roses man than me, because they were a bit before my time.

Carl Froch
Image: Carl Froch prefers Noel to Liam

I wasn't a massive Oasis fan but will pick them just because of the era. I had a couple of their albums and liked 'Slide Away' and 'Wonderwall'. I prefer Noel of the two, so 'Half A World Away'.

Scott Quigg

MANCHESTER, ENGLAND - APRIL 19:  Scott Quigg celebrates after knocking out Tshifhiwa Munyai during the WBA World Super Bantamweight Title fight between Sco
Image: Scott Quigg's entrance is heralded by an Oasis song

It's got to be Oasis, hasn't it! My favourite Oasis song? Well, I walk into one don't I, 'Rock and Roll star.'

Also See:

Jamie Moore

Jamie Moore - Sky Sports
Image: Jamie Moore is banging the drum for one local band

I'm going to have to go with Stone Roses. It's an absolute photo finish, but the only reason I'm going for Stone Roses is because Oasis are Manchester City fans.

If I had to walk out to a Stone Roses track it would be 'Fool's Gold', 100 per cent.
Jamie Moore

If I had to walk out to a Stone Roses track it would be 'Fool's Gold', 100 per cent, because 'I'm no clown and I won't back down' is a line out of the song.

Callum Smith

Callum Smith during the public workout at Manchester Arena.
Image: Callum Smith has set aside city rivalry when it comes to music

I like Oasis, even though I am from Liverpool. I had them on in the car the other day and it is hard to pick one out, but I'll have to go with 'Wonderwall'.

Jim McDonnell

Jim McDonnell
Image: Jim McDonnell revealed his fondness for a famous love song

Well it was a tough one, but I'd go for Oasis just because of the Manchester boxing thing, and the fact they were part of Ricky Hatton's career.

All of them are great and it might not be a classic cheerful song, but 'Wonderwall' is the one for me.

David Coldwell

Well, I cannot stand that kind of music. One or two of the Oasis tunes were alright. If you had to put a gun to my head, I would turn it on them both!

LIVERPOOL, ENGLAND - NOVEMBER 22:  Tony Bellew's trainer David Coldwell shouts instructions during the Eliminator for the WBO World Cruiserqweight Champion
Image: Trainer David Coldwell is not a fan of northern Indie anthems

If forced, I would got with Oasis, and my daughter can play 'Wonderwall' on the guitar, so I will go with that.

Tony Bellew

I would pick Oasis, they are my era, whereas Stone Roses are way before my time. How old do you think I am? To the public I'm 34, but I still look 26.

I would pick Oasis, they are my era, whereas Stone Roses are way before my time. How old do you think I am?
Tony Bellew

I'm going to go for 'Lyla', it's a bit different. That or 'Wonderwall' probably. Dave Coldwell said neither, because he's bald and he's into 'Right Said Fred'.

Watch Jorge Linares vs Anthony Crolla II and a packed undercard, live from the Manchester Arena, from 7pm, Saturday, Sky Sports 1.

Around Sky